The difference between PSA 10 and PSA 9 can mean thousands—or even tens of thousands—of dollars for high-end Pokemon cards. Understanding when this single grade point matters, and whether it's worth pursuing, is critical for collectors and investors. This comprehensive guide breaks down real price differences, explains what separates the grades, and helps you make smarter decisions about grading and purchasing graded cards.
Quick Stats
Average PSA 10 premium over PSA 9 for vintage cards
Vintage card PSA 10 rate at professional grading services
Average price gap for 1st Ed Base Set Charizard (PSA 10 vs 9)
Table of Contents
- Real Price Comparisons: PSA 10 vs PSA 9
- What Separates PSA 10 from PSA 9
- When the Grade Difference Matters Most
- Understanding Population Reports
- Grading ROI: Is It Worth Chasing PSA 10?
- Investment Strategy: Which Grade to Buy
- How to Inspect Cards for PSA 10 Potential
- Common Grading Myths Debunked
- Frequently Asked Questions
Real Price Comparisons: PSA 10 vs PSA 9
Let's look at actual market data for popular Pokemon cards. These prices reflect recent sales (October 2025) and demonstrate how grade premiums vary by card type, age, and population.
Vintage Cards (1999-2003)
| Card | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | Multiplier | Pop 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st Ed Base Charizard | $8,000-12,000 | $45,000-60,000 | 5-7.5x | ~120 |
| Base Set Charizard (Unlimited) | $400-600 | $2,500-3,500 | 5-6x | ~2,800 |
| Base Set Blastoise Holo | $250-350 | $1,200-1,800 | 4-5x | ~1,200 |
| Jungle Pikachu (1st Ed) | $80-120 | $400-600 | 4-5x | ~450 |
| EX Gold Star Charizard | $2,500-3,500 | $15,000-25,000 | 6-7x | ~85 |
Pop 10: Number of PSA 10 copies in existence (approximate). Lower population = higher premium.
Modern Cards (2019-2025)
| Card | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | Multiplier | Pop 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Charizard VMAX (Rainbow) | $150-200 | $350-500 | 2-2.5x | ~5,800 |
| Umbreon VMAX Alt Art | $200-280 | $550-750 | 2.5-3x | ~3,200 |
| Pikachu VMAX (Vivid) | $35-50 | $80-120 | 2-2.5x | ~12,000 |
| Moonbreon (Alt Art) | $250-350 | $700-1,000 | 2.5-3x | ~4,500 |
| Giratina VSTAR (Alt Art) | $80-110 | $180-250 | 2-2.3x | ~8,400 |
Modern cards have significantly higher PSA 10 populations, resulting in lower premiums compared to vintage.
📊 Key Patterns in Grade Premiums
- •Vintage cards: Typically 4-7x premiums for PSA 10 (sometimes 10x+ for extremely rare cards)
- •Modern cards: Usually 2-3x premiums for PSA 10
- •Low population cards: Command highest multipliers regardless of era
- •Popular Pokemon (Charizard, Pikachu): See higher premiums than equally rare but less popular cards
What Separates PSA 10 from PSA 9
The difference between these grades often comes down to microscopic details. Understanding PSA's specific criteria helps you estimate your card's potential grade and decide whether to pursue grading or purchase a specific grade.
PSA 10: Gem Mint
Centering Requirements:
Front: 55/45 or better (nearly perfect)
Back: 75/25 or better
Corners:
All four corners must be perfectly sharp with no visible wear, even under 10x magnification.
Surface:
No scratches, print lines, or surface imperfections visible. Minor factory printing dots acceptable if not distracting.
Edges:
Clean and crisp with no chipping, whitening, or wear.
PSA 9: Mint
Centering Requirements:
Front: 60/40 to 65/35 acceptable
Back: 90/10 acceptable
Corners:
May have one corner with slight touch or minor fuzzing visible only under magnification.
Surface:
One or two minor print imperfections or very light scratches acceptable if not eye-catching.
Edges:
Very slight edge wear or minor roughness acceptable, but no significant chipping.
Common Disqualifiers from PSA 10
Issues That Drop to PSA 9:
- •Centering off by more than 55/45 on front
- •One corner with microscopic wear
- •Minor print line in non-critical area
- •Light surface scratch only visible at certain angles
- •Very minor edge whitening on one edge
Issues That Drop Below PSA 9:
- •Centering worse than 65/35 on front
- •Multiple corners with visible wear
- •Visible scratches on surface (PSA 8 or lower)
- •Edge chipping or significant whitening
- •Any creasing (PSA 6 or lower)
💡 The Reality Check
Most cards that look "perfect" to the naked eye will grade PSA 9. Only cards that are perfect under magnification achieve PSA 10. This is why vintage PSA 10 cards are so rare—print quality and age make flawless examples extremely uncommon.
When the Grade Difference Matters Most
Not all cards see significant premiums from PSA 9 to PSA 10. Understanding when the grade difference drives major value changes helps you make smarter buying and grading decisions.
Grade Difference Matters MOST
- 1.Vintage Base Set holos (1999-2000): 5-8x premiums are standard. Charizard, Blastoise, and Venusaur see the highest multipliers.
- 2.First Edition cards: Already rare, PSA 10 examples are exponentially rarer and command massive premiums.
- 3.Gold Star cards (2004-2007): Low population PSA 10s see 6-10x premiums over PSA 9.
- 4.Cards with PSA 10 populations under 100: Scarcity drives premium multiples regardless of era.
- 5.Trophy cards and tournament prizes: PSA 10 examples can be worth 10x+ PSA 9 due to extreme rarity.
Grade Difference Matters MODERATELY
- 1.Modern alternate art cards: 2.5-3x premiums typical. Visual appeal drives demand at all grades.
- 2.Neo era holos (2000-2002): 3-5x premiums common. Less iconic than Base Set but growing collector demand.
- 3.Modern VMAX/VSTAR rainbow rares: 2-3x premiums for popular Pokemon like Charizard, Pikachu.
- 4.Japanese exclusive promos: Depends on specific card, but typically 2-4x for PSA 10.
Grade Difference Matters LEAST
- 1.Modern bulk holos: 1.5-2x premiums. High PSA 10 populations (10,000+) minimize grade scarcity.
- 2.Recently released sets: Premiums haven't stabilized yet, and 10s are still being graded in high volume.
- 3.Standard V/GX cards: Unless it's a chase card or alternate art, premiums are minimal (1.5-2x).
- 4.Non-holo rares from any era: Generally low absolute values even in PSA 10, minimal premium over PSA 9.
⚖️ Decision Framework
For Grading: Only pursue PSA 10 for cards in the first two categories where premiums justify the risk and cost. Modern bulk holos aren't worth grading even if they look perfect.
For Buying: PSA 9 offers excellent value in the first category (pay 20% of PSA 10 price for similar visual appeal). In the third category, raw Near Mint cards may be smarter purchases than graded copies.
Understanding Population Reports
PSA population reports show how many copies of each card exist at each grade. This data is critical for understanding value and predicting future premiums.
How to Read Population Data
| Population Metric | What It Means | Impact on Value |
|---|---|---|
| Total Graded | How many times this card has been submitted to PSA | Higher = More collector interest |
| PSA 10 Count | Number of Gem Mint 10 copies certified | Lower = Higher PSA 10 premium |
| PSA 10 Rate | (PSA 10s / Total Graded) x 100 | Lower rate = Greater scarcity premium |
| PSA 9/10 Ratio | How many PSA 9s exist for every PSA 10 | Higher ratio = Larger PSA 10 premium |
📚 Case Study: Base Set Charizard
Population Data (October 2025):
- • Total Graded: ~28,000
- • PSA 10: ~2,800 (10% rate)
- • PSA 9: ~9,500 (34% rate)
- • PSA 9/10 Ratio: 3.4:1
What This Tells Us:
- • Only 1 in 10 submissions grades PSA 10
- • 3.4x more PSA 9s create strong demand for 10s
- • Market price: PSA 9 = $500, PSA 10 = $3,000 (6x premium)
- • Premium justified by scarcity and iconic status
Population Sweet Spots for Investment
Ultra-Low Pop (Under 50 PSA 10s)
Highest premiums (10x+), but verify demand exists. Some ultra-low pop cards have low demand, making them hard to sell.
Low Pop (50-500 PSA 10s)
Sweet spot for investment. Scarce enough for premiums (5-8x), liquid enough to sell quickly. Most vintage holos fall here.
Medium Pop (500-5,000 PSA 10s)
Moderate premiums (2-4x). Good for personal collection but less attractive for pure investment. Includes many modern chase cards.
High Pop (5,000+ PSA 10s)
Minimal premiums (1.5-2x). PSA 10 status adds little value. Often not worth grading costs. Most modern bulk rares and recent set holos.
Grading ROI: Is It Worth Chasing PSA 10?
Grading is expensive and success isn't guaranteed. Let's break down the math to determine when pursuing PSA 10 makes financial sense.
Grading Cost Breakdown
| Service Level | Cost Per Card | Turnaround | Total Cost (inc. shipping) |
|---|---|---|---|
| PSA Value | $25 | 65+ business days | ~$40-50 |
| PSA Regular | $75 | 30-40 business days | ~$90-100 |
| PSA Express | $150 | 10-15 business days | ~$165-175 |
Total cost includes grading fee + shipping both ways + insurance for valuable cards.
✓ Positive ROI Scenario
Example: Base Set Holo Blastoise (Near Mint condition)
Scenario A: Grades PSA 10 (15% chance)
PSA 10 Market Value: $1,500
Net Profit: $1,155 (335% ROI)
Scenario B: Grades PSA 9 (65% chance)
PSA 9 Market Value: $350
Net Profit: $5 (1.4% ROI)
Scenario C: Grades PSA 8 or lower (20% chance)
PSA 8 Market Value: $200
Net Loss: -$145 (-42% ROI)
Expected Value: +$189 (55% ROI)
Despite risk of PSA 8-9, high PSA 10 premium makes grading profitable
✕ Negative ROI Scenario
Example: Modern VMAX Holo (Recent Set)
Scenario A: Grades PSA 10 (30% chance)
PSA 10 Market Value: $35
Net Loss: -$25 (-42% ROI)
Scenario B: Grades PSA 9 (60% chance)
PSA 9 Market Value: $18
Net Loss: -$42 (-70% ROI)
Expected Value: -$35 (-58% ROI)
Never grade modern bulk holos—grading costs exceed total card value
📊 Grading Decision Matrix
| Raw Card Value | PSA 10 Premium | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|
| $0-50 | Any | ❌ Don't grade |
| $50-200 | 2x or less | ❌ Don't grade |
| $50-200 | 3x or more | ⚠️ Grade if flawless |
| $200-500 | 2-3x | ⚠️ Grade if flawless |
| $200-500 | 4x or more | ✅ Grade recommended |
| $500+ | Any | ✅ Grade for protection |
Investment Strategy: Which Grade to Buy
For collectors purchasing graded cards, choosing the right grade depends on your goals, budget, and the specific card.
Buy PSA 10 If:
- ✓You're investing long-term (5+ years) in vintage cards
- ✓The card has a PSA 10 population under 500
- ✓You're building a registry set or display collection
- ✓Historical data shows PSA 10 premiums are growing
- ✓It's your favorite card/Pokemon and budget allows
Best For:
Serious investors, completion collectors, cards with low PSA 10 populations
Buy PSA 9 If:
- ✓You want personal collection cards to display/enjoy
- ✓The PSA 10 premium is 5x or higher
- ✓PSA 10 population is extremely high (5,000+)
- ✓You're buying modern cards from recent sets
- ✓You're diversifying across multiple cards vs. one PSA 10
Best For:
Budget-conscious collectors, modern cards, cards with minimal visual difference at PSA 9 vs 10
Real Investment Comparison
Let's say you have $2,000 to invest in Pokemon cards. Here are two strategies:
Strategy A: Single PSA 10
Purchase: 1x Base Set Charizard PSA 10
Cost: $2,000
Pros:
- Iconic card with proven appreciation
- Low PSA 10 population creates scarcity
- Single asset easy to track/sell
Cons:
- No diversification
- All value in one card
- High entry cost limits future purchases
Strategy B: Multiple PSA 9s
Purchase:
- 1x Base Set Charizard PSA 9 ($400)
- 1x Base Set Blastoise PSA 9 ($300)
- 1x Base Set Venusaur PSA 9 ($250)
- 2x Gold Star cards PSA 9 ($500 each)
Total: $1,950
Pros:
- Diversified across 5 premium cards
- Lower individual risk
- More flexibility to sell pieces
Cons:
- Miss PSA 10 appreciation potential
- More cards to track/insure
Author's Take: Strategy B offers better risk-adjusted returns for most collectors. PSA 9 cards provide 80-90% of the visual appeal at 20-30% of the PSA 10 cost. However, if you're a true investor with conviction in a specific card's long-term trajectory, Strategy A can yield superior returns.
🎯 Investment Rule of Thumb
For vintage cards with low PSA 10 populations: Buy PSA 10 if you can afford it—premiums tend to grow over time as supply remains fixed while demand increases.
For modern cards with high PSA 10 populations: Buy PSA 9 or even raw Near Mint—PSA 10 premiums will likely compress as more copies are graded.
How to Inspect Cards for PSA 10 Potential
Before sending cards to PSA, learn to evaluate them like a professional grader. This saves money and prevents disappointment.
Tools You Need
10x Jeweler's Loupe
$10-20 on Amazon. Essential for corner and edge inspection.
Bright LED Light
Natural daylight or 5000K LED. Reveals surface scratches and print lines.
Centering Tool/Ruler
Digital caliper or printable centering guide. Measures border ratios accurately.
Step-by-Step Inspection Process
Check Centering (Most Common Disqualifier)
Measure the borders on all four sides. For PSA 10, left-to-right and top-to-bottom borders must be within 55/45 ratio.
Inspect All Four Corners Under Magnification
Use the loupe to examine each corner at 10x magnification. Any whitening, rounding, or fuzziness = automatic PSA 9 or lower.
Examine Surface at Multiple Angles
Tilt the card under bright light to see scratches, print lines, or indentations. Surface must be flawless for PSA 10.
Check Edges for Whitening or Chipping
Run your eyes along all four edges. Any white spots along the edge (edge wear) = PSA 9 max.
Check Back of Card
Don't forget the back! Centering, corners, surface, and edges all matter on both sides. Back centering can be 75/25 for PSA 10 (more lenient than front).
❌ Red Flags = Not PSA 10
- • Borders obviously uneven
- • Any corner has visible whitening
- • Surface scratches visible without magnification
- • Print lines across artwork
- • Edge whitening on any edge
- • Holo scratching or dullness
- • Indentations or dents (even minor)
- • Back has significant centering issues
If you see any of these, don't waste money grading for PSA 10. The card will likely grade PSA 9 or lower.
Common Grading Myths Debunked
Myth #1: "Pack fresh = automatic PSA 10"
Reality: Only 20-40% of modern pack-fresh cards grade PSA 10 due to centering and factory print quality issues. Vintage cards from the '90s have PSA 10 rates of just 5-15% even when pulled fresh from packs.
Myth #2: "PSA is inconsistent—regrade until you get a 10"
Reality: While minor grading variances exist, PSA is generally consistent. Cards that grade PSA 9 usually have disqualifying flaws for PSA 10. Regrade success rate is only 5-10%, and you'll spend hundreds before getting lucky.
Myth #3: "BGS 9.5 is better than PSA 10"
Reality: BGS 9.5 and PSA 10 trade at similar values, with PSA 10 typically preferred for vintage cards due to market convention. BGS 10 Black Label (all four subgrades 10) is worth significantly more than PSA 10.
Myth #4: "You can't see the difference between PSA 9 and 10"
Reality: Partially true. To the naked eye, most PSA 9s and 10s look identical. However, under magnification or close inspection, PSA 10s have noticeably sharper corners and better centering.
Myth #5: "All PSA 10s will appreciate in value"
Reality: PSA 10s of common modern cards with high populations (10,000+) often decline in value as more copies are graded. Only low-population, high-demand PSA 10s show consistent appreciation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Ready to Build Your Graded Collection?
Use PokeScope to research card values, compare PSA 9 vs PSA 10 pricing, and track your collection's worth across all grades.